Thursday, February 27, 2014
Dear Esther, an artistic experience
Dear Esther: A Piece of Modern Art
Sitting a few rows from the back in a cramped theater-style seat at the Frick Fine Arts Building, I struggled to see what I was looking at. Is that a urinal?
A Work of Art, But Not a Game
![]() |
| New Environments in Dear Esther |
![]() |
| Strange Drawings in Dear Esther |
![]() |
| Flower Gameplay, from http://www.indiegames.com/images/timw/flower2b.jpg |
![]() |
| Journey Gameplay, from http://www.theaveragegamer.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/Journey-Co-op-Barrems.jpg |
Silent Video Game.
Prompt 1: Reviewing the Reviews
Friday, February 21, 2014
Instructions for Self-Evaluations
These are due before class next week. This really isn’t very complicated, but I try to be as specific as possible to avoid misinterpretations.
There are three components to the self-evaluation. You will evaluate yourself on your participation in class, on your participation in the weekly short blog entries due the day before class, and on your participation in commenting on one another’s work. You will evaluate yourself on a five point scale for each category. The criteria are as follows, for each category. Please read the criteria, and send me an email before our next class, which includes the name of each category and your self-evaluation for that category. You may include a paragraph or less commenting on your own work. You may give me links to your best work for the weekly short blog and/or commenting on the work of others. These links are required if you are giving yourself a 4 or 5 in that category; you should be able to easily point out an example of your own excellent work.
In-Class Criteria
5: You always come to class, always participate multiple times, and your part in the discussion is productive (for instance, you might regularly move the overall discussion in a new direction).
4: You come to class, always participate at least once in a given session (alternatively, you might have the occasional off class, but otherwise perform at the 5 level), and your participation is consistently productive.
3: You come to class, and usually have something to say in the course of the session. The value of your participation might be inconsistent, or you might have had several silent classes.
2: You rarely participate, but you pay attention, and occasionally have things to say.
1: You rarely or never participate in class.
“Question” Blog Entries
5: You always do the blog entry, you always put some thought into it, and your work is invariably productive; you would feel comfortable writing a full essay on at least some of these ideas. Your ideas might often show up in class (hopefully with your name attached to them).
4: You haven’t missed any weekly blog entry. While the quality of those entries might vary (and their length probably does), and while only a few of your ideas might have come up class, you feel like some of them could have been the basis of a discussion.
3: You have missed no more than one weekly blog entry. The quality of those entries may be somewhat variable.
2: You do your blog entry more often than not, but may have missed more than one; when you do it, its quality may be inconsistent.
1: You usually don’t do the blog entry at all.
Comments on the work of others
5: You always make your weekly comment on another person’s blog entry. You always put thought into your comment, and you always productively focus on their overall argument, without getting wrapped up in details. You have at least a couple paragraphs of coherent thoughts.
4: The same as 5, except you might have missed an entry, or you might sometimes wander in your focus, or you might have done one or two of them in haste. Generally, though, you offer specific, focused, useful advice.
3: You usually remember to make your weekly comment, but they are often short and/or unfocused on their argument. You might, for instance, usually focus on grammatical or mechanical issues instead of their argument, or you might simply often praise the other person, without offering much in the way of constructive advice.
2: You have commented on others’ work, but you sometimes forget to do so, and you don’t put much effort into it when you do.
1: You don’t usually comment on others’ work.
Comments / questions on Dear Esther & Marcuse
Dear Esther & Marcuse Prompts
Prompt 1: Reviewing the Reviews
I find the reviews of Dear Esther rather interesting, both as ways of thinking about the game and as evidence that there is intelligent life among video game reviewers.Read the following reviews; you may read others as well, if you wish.
http://www.destructoid.com/review-dear-esther-221082.phtml
http://www.ign.com/articles/2012/02/13/dear-esther-review
Using at least these two reviews to help you articulate your viewpoint (you may have use for either Portal or Zork as well), define/argue what Dear Esther is. Is it a game? Is it art? Is it both? (We might also ask whether the terms are mutually exclusive, highly compatible, or somewhere between) Is it something else?
You may, if you wish, use Dear Esther to make a wider point about video games or art, but don’t get distracted by the general point: focus first on defining Dear Esther through analyzing details of it.
p.s. There are various ways you can use the other games to help organize your argument. For instance, you might argue that calling both Zork and Dear Esther games is distracting or inaccurate - Zork and Dear Esther might be more correctly understood as being just as different as, say, a film from a short story.
Prompt 2: Marcuse and Dear Esther (recycled from last week)
Use Marcuse, including specifics, to analyze Dear Esther. Alternatively, you may analyze Dear Esther in relationship with one other work of “popular culture” (I am using the term loosely, not precisely). You should, as usual, have a specific argument, in this case at least inspired by Marcuse (if you disagree in some fundamental way with Marcuse, this essay might help explain why). The most obvious question you might begin with is: “does my chosen work engage in, or try to engage in, the Great Refusal”? Another example: you might argue that Portal helps us challenge Marcuse’s argument that we [cannot] “really distinguish between the mass media as instruments of information and entertainment, and as agents of manipulation and indoctrination?”In other words, the most obvious approach (although by no means the only one) is to use Dear Esther as an example or possibly counterexample of what Marcuse sees as the problems of the modern mass media, either alone or in comparison with another work of mass culture.
Prompt 3: Marcuse Research
Using academic sources only, probably from Pitt’s library (that is, an actual book, or an article(s) from a peer-reviewed journal), present research relating to Marcuse that you think would help the class, and that is at least moving toward an argument. To put it another way: it’s fine to spend most of your space simply presenting one or several interesting sources, but you need to also, at the very least, show us the beginning of an argument, or to pose a question or series of questions which would lead to an argument. A 75%/25% division between research and argument would be fine, although I’d be skeptical of a 90%/10% division.Your sources should be obviously serious and substantive - at least 20 pages of academic writing, and probably more. If you’re using a book, you shouldn’t necessarily read the whole thing, but read at least the introduction, and whatever material deals with a topic of interest to you.
Example topics: how was Marcuse’s work received and used when it was published? How did Marcuse use, and react against, Heidegger? (We haven’t read any Heidegger in this class, but it’s still a functioning example) How can/should we understand Marcuse using either the history of philosophy, or the history of technology? What was the role of Marcuse’s thought in American politics of the 1960s? Etc.
Recommended book: Andrew Feenberg’s The Catastrophe and Redemption of History, and is even available as kindle book, if you’re too lazy to go to the library.
Thursday, February 20, 2014
Marcuse and Portal
Marcuse’s novel “One Dimensional Man,” is most recognized as a specific precarious identification of this present day and age while soon being taken up as a critical indictment of contemporary Western societies, capitalist, and communist. While reading through it, I recalled it as expressing the hopes of an essential philosopher that the freedom and happiness from humans could be prominently extended beyond the one-dimensional thought and behavior in society. This novel contains a certain theory of “advanced industrial society” which describes how many of the changes in productivity, consumption, culture, and people’s thoughts alone have produced a high sense of conformity during the production of needs and aspirations by the prevailing common contraption integrating individuals into the established societies.



